What happens when you don't get a credit on a recording you have worked on?
Suppose you worked on a recording, but you didn't get a credit. Would this matter to you? You bet it would!
Follow RecordProducer.com on Twitter...
One of the thorny issues of record production is that of credits. To a casual purchaser, 'Produced by...' means little or nothing. But to the people involved, credits are everything.
If you are credited on a successful project, even if it's just 'Castanets by...' then you have something you can trade with. You can ring people in the business and say, "I played castanets on...". If your credit was on a significant hit record, then you'll be listened to.
The problem is, as exemplified by a situation recounted in 'Tony Visconti: the Autobiography', that people don't decide beforehand who is going to be credited for what.
And then when the record or CD comes out, some people are going to be disappointed. Often bitterly.
The example from Tony Visconti's book is of Paul McCartney's 'Band on the Run', which is probably the best album from his post-Beatle years.
Visconti and McCartney apparently sat at a piano and worked out some rough ideas for string arrangements (Visconti is a skilled arranger and orchestrator). McCartney wanted some of his ideas reproduced verbatim, others were left extremely vague.
So Visconti went off and wrote the arrangements, which is a complex and detailed task. Humming a melody takes no time at all. Sitting down and writing a score is an altogether weightier process.
The arrangements were overdubbed onto the tracks already recorded by McCartney and the band. One evening, McCartney came round to Visconti's house with a copy of the tapes.
Visconti commented that he was eager to hear his arrangements. McCartney curtly responded that they were not Visconti's arrangements, they were McCartney's arrangements. Thus reducing Visconti's role to that of a mere mechanical.
There was no credit for Visconti on the record.
Some time later, Visconti met John Lennon for the first time and, deep into the conversation, remarked how disappointed he had been not to get a credit for Band on the Run.
Lennon responded, "Even if I whistled a part to an arranger, and it was my idea, I would still give the arranger a credit as orchestrator." And on Band on the Run, Visconti had done much more than that.
Lennon continued, "I was about to call Paul tomorrow and get together with him, but you just reminded me of what a f****** c*** he is."!
All's well that ends well, as Shakespeare said, and Visconti finally did get a credit on the 25th anniversary edition of Band on the Run.
But twenty-five years is an awful long time to wait...
Publication date Sunday March 21, 2010
(You can unsubscribe quickly and easily.)
Discussion on this article's topic...
Saturday March 27, 2010
Thursday March 25, 2010
The McCartney/Visconti article is unfair. If you read McCartneys book "Many Years from Now", you will read of McCartney's acknowledgements of ideas given to him by various people over the years. What Lennon supposedly said is hearsay, it would be something he MIGHT have said, but we can't be sure.It's in his verbal style but it could be inaccurate!
I am a fan of Lennon's, by the way.
Regards
C.Corcoran
Thursday March 18, 2010
Cheers
Jj
Wednesday March 17, 2010
Monday March 15, 2010
UPDATE - Posting of comments has been disabled. RecordProducer.com has been targeted by a botnet posting spam comments. The facility to post comments will return when this problem has been resolved.
We welcome your addition to the discussion on the topic of this article. If you feel that the article is inaccurate in any way, please let us know by e-mail at . We read all messages sent to this address but we cannot promise a reply.
 |
An RP reader asks whether he can record on his workstation and then export tracks to his computer for editing and mixing. Why would he want to do that...? Read more... |
 |
An RP visitor enquires whether the Genelec 8240A with digital inputs and DSP is suitable for the home recording studio. Hmm... Read more... |
 |
So your band has a website. That is so 2009! Why not get the new decade started with an iPhone app that showcases your talent to the (iPhone) world? Read more... |
 |
Sometimes the sound of the electric guitar doesn't quite cut it. But there are ways you can make the guitar sound like more than it is. Much more... Read more... |
 |
A reader asks whether it is allowable to pan low frequency instruments. If not, what would the possible penalty be? Read more... |
 |
Clipping is an eternal problem in audio. It causes terrible distortion and cannot be corrected. Here is the VERY BEST tool to prevent you getting a clip ever again... Read more... |
 |
Jones For Tones is a Vancouver based music production company with a focus on songwriting, owned and operated by session bassist/recording artist Tony Marriott. Read more... |
 |
Your mic might be cardioid, omnidirectional, figure-of-eight or hypercardioid, but what difference will it make to your recording? Read more... |
 |
Early mixing consoles had quadrant faders instead of the linear faders of today. Do they just look pleasantly retro, or do they have advantages we have now lost? Read more... |
 |
Apple's launch of the iPad has created a whole new segment in computing. Should musicians rejoice? Or be very afraid? Read more... |
 |
Setting the gain of the microphone preamplifier correctly is one of the basic skills of audio. So why don't mic preamps need meters? Read more... |
 |
If your monitors are too small to handle deep bass, then there's stuff going on your recordings that you don't know about. Would a subwoofer help? Read more... |
 |
Pro Tools is considered by many to be the king of digital audio workstation software. But it might soon be time for someone else to wear the crown. Here's why... Read more... |
 |
There are more audio formats than you could possibly shake a stick at. But could you find a use for FLAC in your recording process? We think you could. Read more... |
 |
Jamhub is a totally new concept - a rehearsal amp for the whole band. RecordProducer.com asks inventor Steve Skillings all about Jamhub - what it does, where the idea came from, and why you should want one. (There's a prize too!) Read more... |
 |
The artist known as Prince is giving away his new CD. You can't buy it in the shops, you can't buy it online. So in which universe does this make commercial sense? Read more... |
 |
Leaving aside questions of color and pattern, what type of carpet works best in a recording studio environment? Read more... |
 |
What is it about your studio that makes it look and feel like a recording studio, and a nice place to work? Or is it just another room in your house? Read more... |
 |
What makes a hit record? Sometimes it's the song, sometimes it's the sound. But who decides whether a certain 'sound' will sell? Read more... |
 |
Mike Leader of Leader Cinema systems, manufacturers of world class large-scale systems for both music industry and motion picture industry professionals, tells you more about subwoofers than you thought you could possibly want to know... Read more... |
