What important feature do analog tape simulators lack?

It's a strange world where you can buy a secondhand analog tape recorder for less than the price of some tape emulation plug-ins and devices. But which will give you the most authentic sound?

Follow RecordProducer.com on Twitter...

The early days of digital were so exciting. Suddenly you could record without discernable noise and distortion. Prior to that, an important part of the recording process was managing the vast amounts of noise and distortion produced.

And weren't those ultra-clean digital recordings sooooo good?

Err. no. They were not good. It was interesting for a time to be able to record cleanly. But after a while the novelty wore off, and the 'dirty' sound of analog became a longed-for attraction.

So we started buying old vacuum tube gear. That helped. Then plug-ins became available that would 'grungalize' our squeaky-clean digital signals.

And then came analog tape emulators.

But what is it that analog tape emulators actually do?

Analog tape recorders produce a certain kind of distortion. It increases with higher signal levels. It is also symmetrical on positive and negative peaks in the signal, leading to the generation of strong odd-order harmonics.

A single-ended tube amplifier on the other hand is asymmetrical and produces a significant quantity of even-order harmonics.

So a tape emulator sounds different to a tube emulator (or real tubes) and adds another useful tool to the audio toolbox.

Of course, analog tape recorders were also noisy. Tape emulators generally give an option whether you have the noise or not. Believe it or not, it is sometimes useful to have it.

But there's one feature of analog tape that emulators lack. And that is wow and flutter.

One tape emulator actually says this is a good thing, to lack this intrinsic component of the analog tape sound!

Let's be clear... wow is a bad thing. Wow is a noticeable cyclic up/down change in pitch. It is truly horrible.

But flutter is another thing totally. Flutter is a fast and mostly irregular change in pitch. It's far too fast to be perceived as a pitch change. Instead it adds something wonderful to the signal...

Sidebands!

You get sidebands with tubes. Put a clean 1 kHz sine wave into a tube amplifier and turn up the gain. You will get additional frequencies at whole-number multiples of the input frequency.

You will also get intermodulation products with more complex relationships.

But the thing is that they don't move. They are frozen and locked to the input signal.

In analog tape, not only do you get sidebands due to the distortion, you get massively more, and more complex, sidebands due to the flutter. And they change continually.

This is what gives analog tape its incredible rich, warm and involving sound.

But the emulators often miss that. So far...

Publication date Monday August 10, 2009

Discussion on this article's topic...

There is no discussion on this topic yet. You could be the first!

UPDATE - Posting of comments has been disabled. RecordProducer.com has been targeted by a botnet posting spam comments. The facility to post comments will return when this problem has been resolved.

We welcome your addition to the discussion on the topic of this article. If you feel that the article is inaccurate in any way, please let us know by e-mail at . We read all messages sent to this address but we cannot promise a reply.

How to prepare your recordings to be PROFESSIONALLY mixed
	You've got your recordings in hand, you've done your networking and have finally made contact with that one industry professional that can help you launch your career... then here it comes, "I need you to send me your multitrack files so I can remix it." Now what do you do to make that happen? Read more...
Does your system have a subwoofer? Shouldn't your main monitors be able to handle the bass?
	If your monitors are too small to handle deep bass, then there's stuff going on your recordings that you don't know about. Would a subwoofer help? Read more...
$8.70 for a single download? How on earth do they get away with those prices?
	A record label specializing in high quality audio charges $$$ for its tracks. But will you get good value for your money? Read more...
"How can I become a professional mix engineer?"
	An RP reader who is already a pro recording engineer wants to become a (highly paid) mix engineer. How can he achieve this? Read more...
What is a record producer? Do you really want to become one?
	It is probably the most common ambition in music. But many people want to become a record producer without really understanding what it means. Here's the primer... Read more...
Filtering the sound of the vuvuzela from the FIFA World Cup
	Love it or hate it, the sound of the vuvuzela is an intrinsic feature of the FIFA World Cup in South Africa. So what if you hate it? Read more...
How do you back up your data? Do you back up your data?
	If you don't back up your data, then you are headed for sure and certain disaster. It's a question of 'when?', not 'if?' Read more...
Will the iPad change the way you make music?
	Apple's launch of the iPad has created a whole new segment in computing. Should musicians rejoice? Or be very afraid? Read more...
The Amazing Jamhub - Inventor Steve Skillings speaks (and offers a PRIZE!)
	Jamhub is a totally new concept - a rehearsal amp for the whole band. RecordProducer.com asks inventor Steve Skillings all about Jamhub - what it does, where the idea came from, and why you should want one. (There's a prize too!) Read more...
Should your music be more organic?
	The food you eat is mostly factory farmed - grown in chemicals manufactured in a chemical works. But is your music 'factory farmed' too, and does it sound like it? Read more...
When should you use Auto-Tune, and when should you avoid it like the plague?
	Auto-Tune is a powerful vocal tuning software. It can turn an out-of-tune vocal track into a pitch-perfect pro performance. But are there times when you would be better off not using it? Read more...
Counterfeit, pirate or bootleg?
	If you buy CDs at flea markets or car boot sales, you may be buying counterfeit, pirate or bootleg products. Does this matter? What do you need to know? Read more...
One hundred ways to record the snare drum
	Are there a hundred different ways to record the snare drum? The answer is 'Yes!', and you need to understand them all... Read more...
Should your loudspeakers have digital inputs?
	An RP visitor enquires whether the Genelec 8240A with digital inputs and DSP is suitable for the home recording studio. Hmm... Read more...
It's true! Vinyl IS better than digital!!
	It's a topic of endless debate, but really there is no way a stream of digits can beat the real vinyl experience. Read more...
The iPad - it's really quite mediocre
	It was supposed to be a magical and revolutionary device. But now that it's here, it is plain that it really isn't anything special at all. Read more...
Can you use office dividers as acoustic screens in the studio?
	We're all for cutting costs where it doesn't compromise performance, but can office dividers do a good job in the recording studio? Read more...
Does fakery belong in music?
	You're watching a live music show on TV, but something doesn't seem right. Should live music be live? Or should we just expect it to be fake? Read more...
How to record a 'Symphony Band'? Do you need sixty microphones?
	An RP visitor asks how he would record a symphony orchestra. Does it need sixty microphones? Or could you do it with two? Read more...
Flute, clarinet and other woodwind - how much key clicking is too much?
	Try close-miking a flute or any other woodwind instrument and you will pick up a whole load of key clicking. What can you do? How much is too much? Read more...