Mastered music - the shocking truth about what you really hear (with audio)

The mastering loudness war is not yet over, yet the casualties are piling up. Yet here is convincing proof that it is all so wrong...

Follow RecordProducer.com on Twitter...

Of all the techniques in the armory of the loudness warrior, the nuclear option is clipping.

Yes you can compress and make a track louder, you can limit it too and make it louder still. You can use a multi-band compressor and squeeze as much energy as possible into every frequency band.

But if you want ultimate loudness, then all you have to do is turn the gain up until the signal clips. All those pesky 'peaks' are simply sliced off, allowing the bulk of the signal to be much higher in level.

In the 'olden days' of audio, clipping was absolutely forbidden. One clip would get you fired. Well, maybe the second one.

But now clipping is a standard part of the mastering process. The evidence is there to see on commercially released CDs. Where the signal goes to 0 dBFS (full scale) and stays there for four or more consecutive samples, that did not occur as a natural part of the waveform. It's a clip.

But if it makes music louder, and people don't mind, is clipping such a bad thing?

Well I wouldn't be one to stand in the way of market forces, if that's what people really want. But is it what they want...?

Here's a little demonstration that should convince anyone that clipping is a bad thing.

Here's a little track of fairly inoffensive music. The music is compressed and normalized, so that it hovers on and just below 0 dBFS most of the time. But it is not clipped...

(Apologies in advance for the distortions of the AAC encoding process)

music-unclipped.m4a

Now here is the same piece of music that has been raised in level by 6 dB. It's definitely louder...

music-clipped+6dB.m4a

And if I reduce it back down by 6 dB for comparison, it's really hardly any different to the original, is it?

music-clipped+6dB-corrected.m4a

Now here's the trick. I take the new version lowered by 6 dB. It's the same as the original except that the clipped peaks have been lost.

Then I subtract it from the original, leaving only the differences.

Here's what's left...

music-clipped-comparison-phase+6dB.m4a

Hmm... those clicks were what we were trying to get away from when we ditched vinyl for CD, yet they seem to be back again.

To be fair, these are not the exact clicks that are present in the 'mastered' version of the track. These are the peaks that are lost.

However, it's not only the peak itself that you hear, it's the sharp transition where the signal suddenly bends through a near-right angle. And these are certainly present in the 'mastered' version.

So if anyone ever wonders why music can often be tiring to listen to, this is exactly why. Mixed in with the music are thousands and thousands of clicks, just like these.

Of course, when the loudness war really is finally over, the record companies will be able to re-release their back catalog once again in unclipped versions...

Perhaps they know what they are doing after all?

Publication date Monday June 29, 2009

Discussion on this article's topic...

Monday February 22, 2010

Monday February 01, 2010

UPDATE - Posting of comments has been disabled. RecordProducer.com has been targeted by a botnet posting spam comments. The facility to post comments will return when this problem has been resolved.

We welcome your addition to the discussion on the topic of this article. If you feel that the article is inaccurate in any way, please let us know by e-mail at . We read all messages sent to this address but we cannot promise a reply.

High-pass filters, low-pass filters - shouldn't they be low-cut and high-cut?
	Whoever invented this stupid terminology should be force fed with Brussels sprouts for a fortnight. Even the 'experts' can get it wrong. Read more...
Record in a professional studio for £135 ($200) a day?
	A pro recording studio for £135 a day (around $200 USD), with access to just about any exotic gear you could possibly want - could this possibly be true? Read more...
How do you get a good manager?
	A good manager is hard to find. But why do you need one in the first place? And where are you going to look? Read more...
What could you do with NINE microphone polar patterns?
	The ADK A-48 Vintage Valve microphone features no fewer than nine polar patterns. Is this overkill, or the ultimate in fine tuning? Read more...
Who's using the oldest audio software?
	Anyone still using pre-2005 software? Pre-2000?? Pre-1995??? Can anyone go back even further than that? Read more...
Quadrant faders - will they make a comeback?
	Early mixing consoles had quadrant faders instead of the linear faders of today. Do they just look pleasantly retro, or do they have advantages we have now lost? Read more...
How do you record a singer with poor microphone technique?
	You're trying to get a decent recording, but your singer is doing really strange things with the microphone. What do you do? Read more...
Will the iPad change the way you make music?
	Apple's launch of the iPad has created a whole new segment in computing. Should musicians rejoice? Or be very afraid? Read more...
Q: What carpet do you recommend for a studio floor?
	Leaving aside questions of color and pattern, what type of carpet works best in a recording studio environment? Read more...
Output impedance - does it matter how much current an output can supply?
	This is a tricky concept to explain and understand. But once you do understand it you'll feel an awful lot better. In fact, you'll probably feel so good you will consider yourself one of the 'elite' of sound engineering and look down upon lesser mortals who do not understand it... Read more...
Isn't it about time you had your own iPhone app?
	So your band has a website. That is so 2009! Why not get the new decade started with an iPhone app that showcases your talent to the (iPhone) world? Read more...
"How can I become a professional mix engineer?"
	An RP reader who is already a pro recording engineer wants to become a (highly paid) mix engineer. How can he achieve this? Read more...
How to prepare your recordings to be PROFESSIONALLY mixed
	You've got your recordings in hand, you've done your networking and have finally made contact with that one industry professional that can help you launch your career... then here it comes, "I need you to send me your multitrack files so I can remix it." Now what do you do to make that happen? Read more...
Record on a workstation - export to your computer. Could this be the best of both recording worlds?
	An RP reader asks whether he can record on his workstation and then export tracks to his computer for editing and mixing. Why would he want to do that...? Read more...
Your compressor adds noise to your recording. Why does it do that?
	A little bit of compression can often do wonders for a recording. But it always adds noise. Always. Why is this so? What can be done? Read more...
Isn't it time you tried a REALLY different microphone?
	You've tried all the usual microphones and are tired of their sound? Why not try something that is really over the edge... Read more...
The iPad - but some things it does are AMAZING!
	While the iPad might be something less than a computer, it is definitely something more than many of the other computer-like devices in our lives. Read more...
No really, you have NOT seen anything like this before!
	JamHub is billed as 'the silent rehearsal studio'. Whatever it is, there's simply nothing else like it. Read more...
If you use compression on stage, will your sound sparkle, or will unholy feedback ensue?
	The compressor is a great studio tool. But does it work for live sound? Is there a hidden danger that will keep the engineer on his toes? Read more...
Why you should put the soloists behind the choir for recording
	For performance, the soloists stand in front of the choir. But for recording, perhaps they should stand behind. Here's why... Read more...