Does limiting make your audio clip and distort?
Push your levels too high and you will break the bounds of your system's capability. But will a limiter make things any better, or simply act as another source of distortion?
Follow RecordProducer.com on Twitter...
Here's an experiment... Take a section of cleanly recorded audio that is well below the level at which the red lights come on.
Now raise the level, raise it some more, then raise it some more. Your system almost certainly does have the ability to raise the level by as much as you want, although you may have to rummage among your plug-ins to find it.
But by whatever means, raise the level until the red light starts to flicker. Listen carefully for changes in the sound. Continue raising the level until the red light is solidly on and there is absolutely no doubt that your sound is distorted.
What you are listening to is the sound of clipping. Any digital audio system has an upper level beyond which the signal just cannot go. We call this 0 dBFS - zero decibels with respect to full scale.
If you try to raise the signal beyond this level, the tips will be clipped, causing distortion.
By the way, this test should be done at a low monitoring level as it will produce a lot of high frequency energy that could potentially damage your tweeters.
To avoid clipping, you might consider using a limiter. Set correctly, this will prevent the signal level reaching 0 dBFS, so no clipping can occur.
Well, that is the theory. In practice it depends on making the correct settings.
Think of it like this... imagine that you could control the level by hand very quickly so that the signal never went above 0 dBFS. Every time a loud section comes along, you lower the level so that the signal stays within bounds. When it goes quiet again, you can raise the level back up again.
That's exactly what a limiter does. But you can make a limiter respond very much more quickly.
You might therefore be tempted to set a really short 'attack' time - that's the time it takes for the limiter to respond; it has nothing to do with making your signal sound more attacking subjectively.
But when the speed of response approaches 50 milliseconds or less, something interesting happens. The limiter is now fast enough to respond to single cycles of the waveform, at low frequency.
At this point, the limiter has the capability of changing the shape of single cycles of the waveform.
There is a word for that - distortion.
So you have a dilemma. Set the attack time too long and fast peaks may get through and clip. But set it too short and the limiter itself causes distortion. It isn't clipping, but it can sound as bad.
The moral is to be very careful when setting an attack time of less than around 100 milliseconds, to be on the safe side. Listen very carefully, watch for red lights, and perhaps limit a little lower than 0 dBFS, then normalize afterwards to bring the level up to peak.
Publication date Tuesday May 26, 2009
(You can unsubscribe quickly and easily.)
Discussion on this article's topic...
Just like a Frenchy, talking out your ass.
Tuesday April 20, 2010
Sunday February 28, 2010
Saturday February 27, 2010
UPDATE - Posting of comments has been disabled. RecordProducer.com has been targeted by a botnet posting spam comments. The facility to post comments will return when this problem has been resolved.
We welcome your addition to the discussion on the topic of this article. If you feel that the article is inaccurate in any way, please let us know by e-mail at . We read all messages sent to this address but we cannot promise a reply.
 |
You don't need years of music theory training to write for an orchestra. If the sounds are in your head, technology can get them out. Read more... |
 |
It's tricky to find a good place to set up a studio. If you live in an apartment, then unless you live in a very old building with really thick walls, you might as well forget it, or just record the electronic components of your music at home, monitoring on headphones... Read more... |
 |
Do music business lawyers always know what they are doing? Or could they ask you to sign a contract that would not stand up in court? Read more... |
 |
Love it or hate it, the sound of the vuvuzela is an intrinsic feature of the FIFA World Cup in South Africa. So what if you hate it? Read more... |
 |
Do you always connect your effects pedals between your guitar and amplifier. Wow, that's just so retro! Read more... |
 |
One of the most enduring myths in recording has been the endless quest for more and more tracks, which grew exponentially from the real need to overdub in the 60's. Prior to 4 track, overdubs were made by compiling sounds from one machine to another - with a generation loss of sonics every time... Read more... |
 |
Are there a hundred different ways to record the snare drum? The answer is 'Yes!', and you need to understand them all... Read more... |
 |
So your band has a website. That is so 2009! Why not get the new decade started with an iPhone app that showcases your talent to the (iPhone) world? Read more... |
 |
Go to a piano teacher and they will tell you to practice every day. But the one thing they hardly ever tell you is *how* to practice. But the cure for 'wrongnoteitis' might be simpler than you think. Read more... |
 |
We're all for cutting costs where it doesn't compromise performance, but can office dividers do a good job in the recording studio? Read more... |
 |
The world-famous Abbey Road studio complex has been in the news lately. But not here. We'd rather record there than spread more tittle-tattle. Read more... |
 |
The artist known as Prince is giving away his new CD. You can't buy it in the shops, you can't buy it online. So in which universe does this make commercial sense? Read more... |
 |
Some things about Apple's iPad are great. Some things are, er, missing. But how useful is it in the studio right now? Read more... |
 |
The ADK A-48 Vintage Valve microphone features no fewer than nine polar patterns. Is this overkill, or the ultimate in fine tuning? Read more... |
 |
As Roger Waters of Pink Floyd once said, "It doesn't have to be loud. We just like it loud." Well, some people would like it even louder. Is this possible? Read more... |
 |
There are more audio formats than you could possibly shake a stick at. But could you find a use for FLAC in your recording process? We think you could. Read more... |
 |
Everyone should build a loudspeaker at least once in their life. But for this would-be loudspeaker builder, their first attempt was something of a disaster... Read more... |
 |
David Mellor argues that knowing how to position a microphone can make a far bigger difference to the quality of your work than which microphone you choose. Read more... |
 |
It is probably the most common ambition in music. But many people want to become a record producer without really understanding what it means. Here's the primer... Read more... |
 |
If your drum reverbs are hanging around too long, they could be confusing your sound. How long should a drum reverb last? Read more... |
